You’re not going to believe this one…

bredit 0 3

You’re not going to believe this one…

You’re not going to believe this one…

Sorry this is a bit long, TLDR at bottom.

Last night we went out to a modern style French restaurant to celebrate a birthday. I’ve been here before and they have a very decent French heavy wine list, including some Conti and first growths you can see in their small wine cellar. I had narrowed down my selection to 3 wines, a 2014 CdP beaucastle j Perrin, a 2019 Cotê-Rotie Domaine Bott “Semons” and a 2014 Bandol I can’t recall the name of. All around the $250ish range. I asked for a somm to help narrow down which was best right now. A man in a suit walked up (the manager) and informed me the somm was out and he could assist. I explained and he clearly didn’t know anything about them, asked if he could check if they were in stock. He came back and confirmed the Rotie and Bandol were the only in stock. Along with a generic recommendation that one will be bolder. I am pretty versed in French wines but have not had Cotê-Rotie before so I went with that one, ordered from the waiter. He brought a Cotê-Rotie out and I said it looked good but it didn’t exactly look like what I ordered so I confirmed with the waiter twice “this is Domaine Bott “Semons” right?” He examined the back label, confirmed yes, and opened the bottle. Once it was sat down I still didn’t feel right about it so I requested the menu again. You can imagine the “holy fuck” moment when I saw “2019 La Mouline $1250”, the most expensive Rotie in inventory. I immediately notified the waiter, his eyes went wide and just said “Jesus Christ, well that worked out good for you”. I couldn’t believe it. The manager grabbed the wrong bottle, my brother saw him shortly after looking very red in the face!! Needless to say, we realized the caliber of wine and not one drop went to waste! It was definitely still young but opened up beautifully over dinner. Absolutely packed with fresh fruit and balanced acidity. You can just tell by the structure and depth of flavor, this is a serious wine. I am not great with ratings but for me this was a 97 pointer all the way. What a great experience for us, probably not so much so for the manager. 

TL;DR: ordered a $250 dollar Cotê-Rotie and the manager mistakenly brought a 2019 La Mouline that was not realized until after the bottle was opened. They honored the $250 price.

submitted by /u/710_feet_high to r/wine
[link] [comments]