Another blind wine night
| Even in a group that meets regularly, when everyone's bringing something blind, you don't necessarily calibrate correctly and boy did I slum it with the Moulin Touchais '96, a bottle I brought because it was a Gilman 95pt wine and I thought if it showed well we'd probably all want to buy some. It did indeed; on opening it it showed great and it got better and more complex as the evening went on. Everyone immediately pegged its place of origin. The '69 Leroy Echezeaux was a tragedy; it was badly corked, but not so badly that we couldn't all tell how great it was meant to have been. I opened one for the same crew around 15 years ago and it was one of the best Burgundies any of us had ever had, before or since. The host whose bottle it was opened the Bouree as a backup, which was easy to peg as Burgundy but hard to nail down exactly what it was. It was obviously high quality (in that era, Bouree had good holdings and outstanding sources for negoce wines), but there was a softness that made me think '85 and other people thought it could have been from the '90s. I did well on the two bottles on the right, which were Pavie '55 and Ripeau '55 from cold British storage that destroyed the labels but did a great job of preserving the wines. I thought maybe '59 on the Pavie, as it was obviously from a good vintage but was lowish in acidity, and maybe '70 on the Ripeau, and everyone else laughed at me for thinking they might be that old! Surprisingly to all of us, the Ripeau was a class better than the Pavie. I did less well on the Rousseau, which had so much strawberry fruit that I thought it was old school red fruity Chateauneuf. Ah well. [link] [comments] |